Glasgow P4Indy group invited John Drummond to their August meeting today to talk about a Scottish Constitution. John, along with Canon Kenyon Wright, was one of the founders of the Constitutional Commission, back in 2005. And on the Commission’s website you find these three principles underpinning how they have tried to progress the idea of a written constitution for Scotland:
The work of the Constitutional Commission starts from three axioms. Firstly, that legitimate sovereignty in Scotland resides in the “whole community of the realm”, and not in the Queen-in-Parliament at Westminster.
Secondly, that a written and entrenched Constitution, endorsed by the whole community, guaranteeing the rights of citizens, and delimiting the powers, duties and responsibilities of the institutions of State, is necessary in order to establish the right relationship between the State and the people in a liberal democracy.
Thirdly, that liberal democracy cannot exist merely in procedural terms, but must be sustained by civic, humane and democratic values.
you can find out more here: Constitutional Commission John is currently giving this talk to Indy supporting groups all over Scotland so if you’re interested, contact him via this website.
The video below is John giving the talk a few months back. It’s approximately what he said in Glasgow today. But because since this version from March 2019, the UK is in the grip of a constitutional crisis, we heard a lot more about the current attempts by Boris Johnson to prorogue Parliament and what that could presage for the Scottish independence movement.
Glasgow and Edinburgh P4Indy groups were up in Oban yesterday. Along with 7000 others according to the reports we’ve seen. I see Robert the Bruce came as well. I particularly like the penguins and seals for Indy and they didn’t mind when the showers came through! If there were other P4Indy groups there too, let us know and we can add your photos.
Some time ago IndyLive Radio put out a call for a Forces Veteran to talk on their programme. About 40 veterans turned up! Those veterans stayed in touch, formed Veterans for Scottish Independence and the group has progressed from there.
Our Glasgow P4Indy Group was interested in hearing from independence supporters who have been or are members of the UK Armed Forces. We know from speaking to people at our street stall that some No voters are influenced by a sense of loyalty to UK, and its history. Often that loyalty includes a feeling that supporting independence is somehow being disloyal to those Scots men and women, past and present, who serve in our Armed Forces. We have been wondering how we might best talk to people who feel that way. Loyalty is after all a positive value to hold.
So we contacted the Veterans group to ask if someone could come to speak to us and as a result Russ Denny came along to our May meeting. Russ joined up when he was 17 years old because he needed a job, and he served in the Army for 27 years.
Our Glasgow people very much appreciated hearing Russ’ insights from his own military background and his passion for Scottish independence. This is what Jim Stamper, one of our Glasgow Group members writes of what Russ said and the discussion afterwards,
Some general observations from Russ
Generally soldiers fight for their comrades not for Queen and Country.
There was a pride in local Scottish regiments which largely stopped with the amalgamation into the 1st and 2nd Scottish Infantry Battalions – one of which is based in England. Personnel are not all Scots but mixed Commonwealth peoples.
The UK Forces actively recruit Commonwealth people and are still not managing to recruit enough. Forces are cut year after year and there are currently about 70,000 troops.
Values and standards demanded of Forces include moral courage – to speak out when something is not right.
The annual commemoration at the Cenotaph is shown as a great display of veneration by Queen and politicians for the sacrifices made by our Armed Forces. While the troops are there for four hours the Queen arrives 5 minutes before the cameras start and leaves 5 minutes after they stop. The politicians are maybe there 20 minutes before and leave 20 minutes after.
Some common mistaken views, misinformation and downright lies that we might hear regarding how members of the Armed Forces feel about Scottish independence.
It is often stated forces personnel took the Oath of Allegiance so can’t support Scottish Independence. The Oath of Allegiance is to the Queen, not the country – there are many serving in the British Army from independent Commonwealth countries.
Forces personnel are ordinary people, the same variety of people as elsewhere. It is not true that all members of the Forces are against independence. Media gets away with saying this because forces personnel are not allowed to speak out.
The claim that those supporting independence are ‘spitting on the graves of fallen comrades’ makes Forces personnel angry. Many who died were African, Indian and of other independent nations.
There is also the lie that their pensions are at risk with independence. Fijian soldiers get their pension OK.
Defence needs after independence
Scotland contributes about £3 billion / year to UK defence. Whereas for an effective Scottish North Atlantic defence force – ie one which actually has ships around the Scottish coastline unlike now – the maximum would be £1.6 billion / year.
On becoming independent, Scotland would be due its share of UK military assets. So we wouldn’t be starting from scratch to set up a Scottish defence force.
Arguing to keeping Trident for jobs is likened to not curing the plague because it would mean less jobs for body collectors and grave diggers. Only 350 jobs are directly related to the nuclear weapons. A high number of workers at Faslane are transient workers from outwith Scotland.
Looking after personnel after they leave the Forces:
If someone has served their full term, which is 18 years or reaching 40 years of age, then they get an MOD pension at the point when they leave the Forces. If they have served a shorter term, then they don’t get their MOD pension until they reach normal retirement age. They will generally have saved nothing and will have no accommodation.
For many it also like leaving a family.
Many find it very difficult to adjust to civilian life.
These issues need dealt with. There is an Armed Forces Covenant encapsulating the moral obligation to those who serve, have served, their families and the bereaved. This is intended to ensure they should face no disadvantage compared to other citizens in the provision of public and commercial services.
If you served 20 years abroad this should be taken to be the equivalent of having worked 20 years in UK when considered for housing, loans, mortgages etc. If you leave forces with illness related to the work then that should be covered.
Conservative and Labour Governments have largely left it up to local government but without providing sufficient funding to them. Keith Brown of SNP and others have spoken out about this inadequacy but this has not been picked up by the media.
The Veterans for Independence group run their own street all and their members are often also in other Indy groups. They go on independence marches and aim to make themselves visible, similar to English Scots for Yes, but are not allowed to wear uniform. After hearing Russ talking, our group think that it would be very helpful to have Veterans for Indy people present at our and other pro-independence groups’ stalls.
The Twitter handle for the Veterans is @SoldierWhy Or click here to go to their Facebook page.
Thank you, Russ, for taking the time to come along to our meeting!
The Netherlands for Scottish Independence March & Rally was held on 25May in the Hague. One of the invited speakers was our own Mary McCabe, a member of the Glasgow Group an co-convenor of our National Group.
As well as showing off our P4Indy T-shirt, Mary told the audience how we are campaigning in Scotland. She also told them the background to setting up the Glasgow P4Indy choir “The Warblers” and did a solo rendition of our Warblers’ song “The Union – A Tragedy”. After all that she regaled the Hague audience with events from three years ago at the Yes Arts Festival – that’s YES as in Yarrow, Ettrick and Selkirk – and a conversation she had with the Duke of Buccleuch who was handing out the prizes, one of which was for Mary’s poem “The Merch o’ the Babyboomers”. She finishes by reciting the poem to much warm applause.
Yesterday saw the first of the AUOB marches wend its way through Glasgow. It definitely wasn’t the right time to try exiting the M8 at Charing Cross! Police reckon 35,000 made it Glasgow Green but unofficial tallies put it at nearer 80,000. Either way it was a lot of independence supporters.
Here’s how Mary McCabe, one of our Glasgow P4Indy members and co-convenor of the Nationial P4Indy Group , describes it:
Yesterday was a great success for the pro-Indy movementl. Depending on whom you believe, numbers ranged from 150,000 on the total march to 35,000 actually making it all the way to Glasgow Green. At the Green, there were lots of stalls including our Pensioners for Indy double stall, lots of speeches and live music – with an efficient sound system! Yet at the end the park was so pristine clean that the organisers proudly printed a picture of it on FB.
Our new unicorn Greater Glasgow Pensioners banner shimmered beautifully above all the flags made a great show and was photographed and commented on several times. We didn’t get to all march together as planned; those who arrived early at the meeting point at the Suffragette Tree were moved on to different spots by stewards so that when I arrived with the banner there were only two – Jeannie Campbell and Brian Watson – left. As the march advanced up Kelvin Way the three of us slipped into a natural space in the parade – we genuinely didn’t realise this counted as queue-jumping! Meanwhile the large Edinburgh Pensioners for Indy contingent had to wait for over an hour on a hill in Kelvingrove Park before being allocated a slot and given the go-ahead. Still, and we all got to Glasgow Green in the end.
We had a double stall using both new gazebos. There were half a dozen of us serving and we were all kept busy with queues the whole time. The food and drink flew off the shelves. All 20 of the T-shirts were sold and there’s a waiting list of folk who were too late to get one (I’ll be ordering more this week). Virtually all of Sheena’s jewellery sold too. We were kept busy till after 6.30. The takings haven’t been counted yet but they must amount to several hundred.
Want a T-shirt? Send us a message via the Contact Form from the top of the page and we’ll send you details of how to get one.
The remaining All Under One Banner marches for 2019 are:
Galashiels June 1st
Oban 15th June
Ayr 6th July
Campbeltown 27th July
Aberdeen 17th August
Perth 7th September
Edinburgh 5th October
It would be great to have big turnouts of P4Indy. I will be bringing the banner to every rally and several Penioners have said they’re planning to go. If the Waverley is repaired by the end of July it’s a lovely sail down to Campbeltown. The turnout at the smaller towns is likely to be 10,000 to 20,000 and at Edinburgh at least 150,000. Everyone smiling and singing with the crowds on the pavements waving and smiling back at us. At the end there’s music, speeches and stuff to eat and buy in a park. A great family day out.
The serious purpose is even more important: when people witness thousands of friendly cheerful folk, some from far afield, demonstrating for independence down their own high streets it gets harder for Unionists and their friends in the media to claim “There’s no appetite for independence. Nobody wants another referendum. Everybody’s bored with politics. Referendums are ugly and divisive.” If anybody feels like going further afield The Netherlands for Scottish Independence rally is on Saturday May 25th at the Hague. More details here: Netherlands Scottish Independence Rally. I attended the previous two years and will be going again this year wearing the new unicorn T-shirt and singing our song on the platform. Usually around 200 turn up and there are good speeches and music. No requirement to speak Dutch!
Some more photos, mainly taken by members of our Glasgow group.